Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Using Your Brain: On Homos, Popes, and Douches


I hate to tell you this, but if you think homosexuality is “evil” or “wrong,” or if you think everyone shouldn’t have the right to marry the person they love…I think you’re a douche.

BUT YOU CAN’T SAY THAT!

Why not?

BECAUSE MY RELIGION!  My religion tells me homosexuality is an abomination so you can’t think I’m a douche!

Nope, I still think you’re a douche.  Know why?  Because I think people should use their fucking brains.

You don’t get to hide behind forms of ignorance within your religion and then walk around with moral impunity.  You don’t.  I don’t have to be “tolerant” of your intolerance, and not being tolerant of your intolerance is not even close to real religious discrimination.  I don’t have to let you enact hate on people.

You also don’t get to play the “love the sinner, hate the sin” card with me on this.  You don’t get to insist that you love homosexuals but that you believe that a homosexual “lifestyle” is immoral.  You don’t get to say, “No no, I love YOU as a PERSON, I just think your life is sinful and wrong.”  That’s not love.  That’s hate dressed up in a polite hat.  That’s just hate without the guts to admit to it.  It’s COWARDLY hate.  Yes, my friend, it’s still hate – it’s just hate that allows you to be smug, superior, and condescending at the same time.

Do I think you’re purposefully being a douche?  Not necessarily.  Because hate isn’t always intentional or conscious.  You might think your hate is love.  It’s not.  And we should recognize these things in ourselves and try to be better.

Do I think you’re ENTIRELY a douche?  Probably not.  People can have douchey positions on things and still not be all douche, you know what I’m saying?  You could be otherwise a good person, but still be a real shitheel when it comes to this one thing. 

Which is why I facepalm every time someone defends the new pope’s comments on homosexuality by screaming, “BUT HE WASHES THE FEET OF AIDS PATIENTS!” 

One.  Stop equating AIDS with homosexuality, or attempting to appeal to my pro-equality position by insinuating that supporting AIDS patients is basically the same as supporting homosexuals, or that supporting AIDS patients in their capacity as AIDS patients somehow makes up for casting hatred toward a specific group of people.

Two.  GOOD FOR HIM!  That’s awesome and symbolic and I absolutely grant you that this pope will probably do more for the poor and vulnerable in developing nations than any other.  I look forward to the progress he can potentially bring to that area of social justice.  But that doesn’t mean I don’t think his positions on sexuality suck. 

I know, I know.  He’s the Pope.  The leader of the Catholic Church.  And the Catholic Church does not believe in birth control, homosexuality, etc.  Asking a pope to be progressive on sexual and reproductive rights is like expecting the Republican nominee for president to like big government.  If he believed in those things, he wouldn’t be nominated as a representative of an organization that expressly does NOT believe in those things.

But here’s the thing…many, many Catholics DO believe in birth control, in equal rights for everyone, including homosexuals.  In fact, providing equal rights for everyone is actually a very Catholic thing to believe in, philosophically speaking.  

If I’ve learned anything from growing up around the Catholic Church, it’s that cognitive dissonance doesn’t seem to cause much alarm. 

On the one hand, the ability to accept things that don’t always make sense is what allows for faith in the first place.  And this is not a bad thing.  It’s also a crucial part of other forms of belief, especially when it comes to things like art, and even history.  (And no, I don’t think religion and science have to be opposed on this front.)

On the other hand, though, the disinclination to at least recognize when beliefs are harmful or untenable even WITHIN the teachings of a particular faith, is at best naïve ignorance and at worst willful disregard.  It’s destructive.  And it bankrupts one of the most productive parts of faith – epistemological exploration.  Faith should be about questions, not definitive answers.  I think a lot of Catholics get this, and it’s a shame that the official Church often lets it be forgotten (or at least often pretends that it’s upholding the idea when it’s really not). 

When religion becomes more about doctrine and less about living faith, it turns into a standardized test.  Instead of teaching to the test, we should be encouraging the active use of our inquisitive faculties.  We should be finding ways to push our brains to think thoughts we haven’t thought before, because the greatest resource in the push for good in the world is the potential of what people are allowed to imagine.   That means allowing them to disagree without casting them out.  That means allowing them to think OUTSIDE Church doctrine, instead of only within its narrow confines.

So yes, in short, I think people should use their fucking brains.  And I think that, given the opportunity to use their brains a little more critically, more Catholics will come to the conclusion that denying a person dignity, autonomy, and equal rights specifically because of who they love is just plain unCatholic.  And I think this extrapolates quite nicely to other denominations and religions.

So I don’t think I’m out of line when I again tell you that if you think homosexuality is an abomination, I think you’re a douche.

That doesn’t necessarily mean I think you’re a bad person.  It means I think you need to use your brain with regard to this particular situation.  Don’t hide behind religious talking points or cheat sheets, or insist that the Bible tells you so.  The Bible says a lot of things.  Use your brain.  If you still come to the conclusion that homosexuality is an abomination…well…use your brain harder.  And if you STILL come to the conclusion that homosexuality is an abomination – not because an old dude told you so or because your family informed you that that’s what you believe (or because you just think it's "icky"), but because, after truly exploring the world around you and using your critical thinking skills, you decide that this position is the right one – well, I disagree wholeheartedly, and I’m disappointed.  But at least you used your brain!

Or maybe I am out of line, and I’M the douche.  You’re allowed to think that, as long as you use your brain to do it.

No comments:

Post a Comment